Fast read
Choosing between a highly integrated battery system and a more traditional modular one depends on your priorities for future-proofing, redundancy, and installation. An all-in-one system with expansion options offers simplicity and high power, while a component-based modular system provides greater initial flexibility and reliability. Both are excellent options that may qualify for government rebates, but your ideal choice will hinge on your home's current and future energy needs.
Integrated vs. Modular: Choosing the Right Home Battery
Deciding on the right home battery is a significant step towards energy independence. A common question is whether it’s better to go with a highly integrated, all-in-one battery system or to opt for a system of smaller, stackable units that can grow with you.
Both approaches have valid merits, and the best choice often comes down to your specific circumstances, including your budget, your home’s energy consumption, and your future plans. Let’s walk through the key differences to help you make a confident decision.
What is the difference between a ‘highly integrated’ and a ‘modular’ battery?
First, let’s clarify the terms. A “highly integrated” battery is a system where the battery, inverter, and control software are combined into a single, self-contained unit with a fixed base storage capacity. The Tesla Powerwall 3 is a well-known example, offering 13.5 kWh of storage capacity and a powerful built-in solar inverter in one sleek box. Unlike its predecessors, the Powerwall 3 is now expandable; you can add up to three additional battery-only “Expansion Pack” units to increase total storage.
A traditional “modular” or “stackable” battery system is like building with Lego. It consists of individual battery modules, typically with smaller capacities (e.g., 3-8 kWh), that are stacked or connected to a separate hybrid inverter to create the desired total capacity. This component-based approach is used by innovative brands like Sigenergy and industry staples like Sungrow. You can start with a few modules and add more later if your energy needs increase.
Flexibility and future-proofing: The case for modular batteries
The primary advantage of a component-based modular system is its incredible flexibility. Your life isn’t static, and your energy needs will likely change. You might buy an electric vehicle (EV), install a pool pump, or welcome new family members. With a stackable battery, you can easily increase your storage capacity by having an accredited installer add another module to your existing stack.
This “pay-as-you-grow” approach can be more cost-effective in the long run. You avoid over-investing in a large capacity you don’t currently need, with the peace of mind that you can expand later without replacing the entire system.
For example, a brand like Sigenergy offers its SigenStor system, an all-in-one tower that combines the inverter with stackable battery modules of 5.38 kWh or 8.06 kWh. This makes it highly adaptable, allowing for up to six battery modules in a single stack for a total capacity of up to 48 kWh. Similarly, Sungrow’s popular SBR series is designed to be paired with a Sungrow hybrid inverter and allows you to stack modules of 3.2 kWh each, with a minimum starting configuration of three modules for 9.6 kWh of capacity, going up to 25.6 kWh in a single stack.
Simplicity and power: The case for a highly integrated battery
On the other hand, the appeal of a highly integrated battery like the Tesla Powerwall 3 lies in its simplicity and performance. It is a well-integrated, all-in-one solution that includes the battery, a powerful built-in solar inverter, and sophisticated software in one package.
This can simplify the installation process and often results in a very clean, aesthetically pleasing setup in your garage or on an external wall. For homeowners who want a straightforward, high-performance system from a globally recognised brand, an integrated battery is a very strong contender. The Australian version of the Powerwall 3 delivers a very high continuous power output of up to 11.5 kW, which is excellent for homes with multiple high-draw appliances that might run at the same time.
Redundancy and reliability: What happens if something goes wrong?
An important, but often overlooked, consideration is system reliability. This is where traditional modular systems have a distinct edge. In a stackable system, if one battery module fails, it can often be isolated or replaced without the entire system going offline. The remaining healthy modules can continue to power your home, providing a level of redundancy that is crucial if you rely on your battery for backup power.
With an integrated battery where the inverter and controls are in a single unit, a major fault can mean a complete shutdown of your energy storage and solar production. While these systems are built to be highly reliable with excellent warranties, they can represent a single point of failure. If an issue does occur, you could be without storage until a technician can perform a repair or replacement.
Installation and cost considerations
When comparing costs, it’s essential to look at the total installed price, not just the unit cost.
For integrated batteries, the upfront cost for a single large battery like a Tesla Powerwall 3 is significant. However, because it includes an integrated solar inverter, it can sometimes work out cheaper for a brand-new solar-and-battery installation compared to buying a separate hybrid inverter and battery stack.
For modular batteries, a component-based system might have a lower entry cost because you can start with a smaller capacity. For instance, a Sungrow 9.6 kWh system requires the purchase of the battery modules and a separate Sungrow hybrid inverter, which together form the complete system. In contrast, a system like the Sigenergy SigenStor is an all-in-one design that already includes the inverter with its stackable batteries. The installation of modular systems can be simpler as individual components are lighter and easier for a single technician to handle. Adding capacity later is also a relatively straightforward job for an electrician.
It’s important to note that the federal government’s Cheaper Home Batteries Program, starting July 1, 2025, will provide an upfront discount on the cost of eligible systems. This benefit is delivered by extending the existing Small-scale Renewable Energy Scheme (SRES) and will typically be applied by your installer, reducing the purchase price directly.
Which one is right for your home?
The final decision rests on your priorities:
Choose a modular (component-based) battery if you want the flexibility to easily and cost-effectively add more storage capacity in the future, you value system redundancy to minimise the risk of a complete system failure, or your budget is tighter initially and you prefer to start smaller and expand later.
Choose a highly integrated battery if you are installing a completely new solar and battery system and want a streamlined solution, you prioritise maximum power output to run many large appliances at once, or you prefer a simple, all-in-one package from a well-established brand and have the budget for the upfront investment, while still having options for future expansion.
Ultimately, both paths lead to greater energy independence and lower power bills. The key is to choose the system that aligns best with your home’s unique energy journey. If you’re unsure, discussing your usage patterns and future plans with an accredited installer can provide invaluable clarity.
